Peanut Butter Sampler

Every product is independently selected by us. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.

We all know someone who is nutty for peanut butter. Wouldn’t it be great to send not just one jar but six? YUM!

Uncommon Goods carries B. Happy Peanut Butter, made in small batches by a family-run peanut butter business launched in Zionsville, Indiana.

Mail order peanut butter gifts

B. Happy Peanut Butter is available at Uncommon Goods

If you know someone who liberally spreads peanut butter on everything, or just eats it from the jar, imagine how happy they’ll be for being treated to flavors that cravings are made of. The Peanut Butter Sampler includes 6 oz jars of:

Happy Trails Mix: Flaxseed, chocolate chips, raisins, split peanuts

White Chocolate Pretzel: Pretzel pieces, white chocolate chips

Snickerdoodle: Snickerdoodle popcorn

Chocolate Toffee: Milk chocolate, bits of toffee, rice crispies

Keep Smunchy: Honey roasted peanuts

Chocolate Coconut: Dark chocolate, shredded coconut, almonds

Measurements 2.75″ diameter x 2.5″ H; 6 oz. capacity. Refrigeration not required

Bear in mind, these peanut butters are on the sweet side–so they are not for your Paleo-eating friends who avoid sugar. If you’re shopping for them, check out the organic and raw nut selection at Nuts.com.

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: $40 for a sampler of 6 jars

Shipping: Economy shipping begins at $7.95

Take me there! Uncommon Goods Peanut Butter Sampler

Let’s Go Nuts.com

Fresh Walnuts from Nuts.com

Organic, Raw, Shelled Walnuts from Nuts.com

How do you like your nuts? Fresh, of course. We mean after that. Do you want them in the shell, shelled, roasted, boiled, raw, organic, salted, unsalted, mixed, spiced, candied, chocolate enrobed? We could go on…

Nuts.com has just about any type of nut you can think of and so much more! Nut flours, nut butters, dried fruits, and an extensive selection of candies. But what’s really helpful is they let you completely customize a tray of nuts and other goodies like dried fruit (organic options too), and candies, so you can really tailor your gift to individual tastes. That’s genius!

For those looking for party favors or themed gifts, they list their candy options by color.

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: It all depends on what you choose but in general expect $10 a pound (give or take) for nuts. Some candies begin as low as $4 a pound. For dried fruit, again, it depends on your selection. Expect $8 per pound (again, give or take).

Shipping: USPS, UPS and FedEx Ground Shipping options keep shipping costs reasonable

Location: New Jersey

Take me there!: www.nuts.com