Cookie Dough Cafe

Mail Order Cookie Dough

Monster dough is creamy trail mix cookie dough in a jar!

For all of us who are cookie dough lovers, we can now skip the baking part and just enjoy the dough.

Cookie Dough Cafe has created edible gourmet cookie dough specifically to be enjoyed unbaked. Available in pint and individual sizes, Cookie Dough Cafe uses real cookie dough ingredients, minus the eggs, and then loads the dough with chocolate chips and brand-name mix-ins like M&Ms and Oreos. Flavors include Classic Chocolate Chip, Cookies & Cream, Monster, shown above, and Naked (just the dough).

If the Cookie Dough Cafe seems vaguely familiar, it may be because you saw this women-owned business on Shark Tank.

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: $50 for 4 pints
Shipping: When we checked in was $19.99 for ground shipping of 4 pints.
Locations: You may find this product in a specialty grocer near you, or online at And it’s now available in bulk via Amazon: The Cookie Dough Cafe Gourmet Edible Cookie Dough, Chocolate Chip, 16 Ounce

Peanut Butter Sampler

Every product is independently selected by us. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.

We all know someone who is nutty for peanut butter. Wouldn’t it be great to send not just one jar but six? YUM!

Uncommon Goods carries B. Happy Peanut Butter, made in small batches by a family-run peanut butter business launched in Zionsville, Indiana.

Mail order peanut butter gifts

B. Happy Peanut Butter is available at Uncommon Goods

If you know someone who liberally spreads peanut butter on everything, or just eats it from the jar, imagine how happy they’ll be for being treated to flavors that cravings are made of. The Peanut Butter Sampler includes 6 oz jars of:

Happy Trails Mix: Flaxseed, chocolate chips, raisins, split peanuts

White Chocolate Pretzel: Pretzel pieces, white chocolate chips

Snickerdoodle: Snickerdoodle popcorn

Chocolate Toffee: Milk chocolate, bits of toffee, rice crispies

Keep Smunchy: Honey roasted peanuts

Chocolate Coconut: Dark chocolate, shredded coconut, almonds

Measurements 2.75″ diameter x 2.5″ H; 6 oz. capacity. Refrigeration not required

Bear in mind, these peanut butters are on the sweet side–so they are not for your Paleo-eating friends who avoid sugar. If you’re shopping for them, check out the organic and raw nut selection at

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: $40 for a sampler of 6 jars

Shipping: Economy shipping begins at $7.95

Take me there! Uncommon Goods Peanut Butter Sampler

Oh Honey!

Isn’t it wonderful when you can send the gift you would love to receive? Bee Raw Honey offers a wealth of beautiful glass jars, and precious vials of honey that present a feast for the eyes and the palate. From hostess to holiday gifts, and every occasion in between, Bee Raw Honey products have won fans like Oprah, and acclaim in The New York Times, Food & Wine, and Martha Stewart Living. Here’s what’s on our wish list:

Online mail order raw honey

A delicious pairing of honey from Bee Raw with Cheese from Murray’s Cheese

The Cheese and Honey Pairings

Bee Raw has teamed up with one of our favorites, Murray’s Cheese, to pair four vials of their delicious honeys with four delicious cheeses. Yeah, send this and you’ve just won the “sophisticated gift giver of the year” award. Prices start at $78.  Bonus: shipping is included. Take me there!

Online mail order raw honey

Walnuts in honey infused with thyme and lemon

Lemon Walnut Honey

Lancaster, PA Wildflower Honey, infused with homegrown thyme and lemon zest enrobe toasted walnuts and combine to create a perfectly suited condiment for a salty blue cheese or with a fresh ricotta or Greek yogurt as a morning treat. Prices start at $16.50 for a 10.5 oz jar. Take me there!

Camomile tea, raspberry honey and a beeswax candle. Ahhhh....

Camomile tea, raspberry honey and a beeswax candle. Ahhhh….

The Ultimate Caring Gift

The perfect “thinking of you” gift, “get well quick” gift, a “hard job well done” gift, or “wish I could be there to give you a hug” gift. A cup of fine chamomile tea lightly sweetened with Bee Raw’s Wild Raspberry Honey and the wafting warmth and scent of a hand poured beeswax candle. This gift lets someone special know you care. Pricing: $49. Take me there!

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: Beautiful gifts start at $15+

Shipping: You can check shipping before you input your billing and shipping information

Take me there! Bee Raw

Tastes of Chicago

Mail Order Pizza From Chicago

Maxwell’s Polish Sausage Kit & Two Deep Dish Pizzas

Deep dish pizza, Chicago “dogs,” Polish sausage, Garretts popcorn—if it’s famous in Chicago, you can order it at Lou Malnati’s Tastes of Chicago. You can shop by Chicago brands, by food categories, or by celebration.

We can assure you if it’s a Chicago deep dish pizza you’re craving, you’re not ordering just any deep dish pizza. Malnati’s deep dish pizza was featured on Bobby’ Flay’s Throw Down, and, while Bobby made a valiant culinary effort, Malnati’s won.

Whether you want to quench your own craving, or send a taste of Chicago to a Chicagoan far from home, Tastes of Chicago has got you covered.

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: Plan on at least $50+ (but the pricing includes standard shipping!)

Shipping: Included

Gift Cards: Yes

Corporate Gifts: Yes

Take me there!

Callie’s Charleston Biscuits

We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy via links on our site. Learn more.

Online mail order southern ham biscuits

Callie’s Charleston Buttermilk Biscuits with Ham. Yes, please.

Southern buttermilk biscuits, ham biscuits, cheese & chive biscuits. A delivery of two dozen biscuits from Callie’s is as if a southern grandmother sent you a care package.

If you grew up in the south, you’ll understand how a good buttermilk biscuit can have a life-long hold on you. Buttery, flaky, and tender, Callie’s biscuits are almost everything you’d want a biscuit to be. Reading Callie’s ingredient list revealed a special ingredient: cream cheese.

Now, sure, if you want to make biscuits yourself Callie provided her wonderful recipe to the Washington Post: Callie’s Biscuit Recipe.

Here’s a tip. Not any flour will do. When Callie’s recipe calls for White Lily brand self-rising flour, well, good luck in finding that north of the Mason-Dixon line. For you biscuit lovers reading this, I know from first-hand experience that Kentucky biscuit makers favor Martha White’s brand self-rising flour.

But for those who want a tender biscuit without the work, Callie’s has you covered! You can order two dozen classic buttermilk biscuits or maybe their ham biscuits, which use finely chopped artisanal Virginia Country Ham, Dijon mustard butter and their signature cheese and chive biscuit.

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: $40 for 2 dozen biscuits (serves 8 – 10 people), $45 for 2 dozen ham biscuits

Shipping: Ships with a reusable cooler and a gel ice pack, so 2-day shipping is pricey. $20 from NC to NY.

Take me there!

Let’s Go

Fresh Walnuts from

Organic, Raw, Shelled Walnuts from

How do you like your nuts? Fresh, of course. We mean after that. Do you want them in the shell, shelled, roasted, boiled, raw, organic, salted, unsalted, mixed, spiced, candied, chocolate enrobed? We could go on… has just about any type of nut you can think of and so much more! Nut flours, nut butters, dried fruits, and an extensive selection of candies. But what’s really helpful is they let you completely customize a tray of nuts and other goodies like dried fruit (organic options too), and candies, so you can really tailor your gift to individual tastes. That’s genius!

For those looking for party favors or themed gifts, they list their candy options by color.

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: It all depends on what you choose but in general expect $10 a pound (give or take) for nuts. Some candies begin as low as $4 a pound. For dried fruit, again, it depends on your selection. Expect $8 per pound (again, give or take).

Shipping: USPS, UPS and FedEx Ground Shipping options keep shipping costs reasonable

Location: New Jersey

Take me there!:

Hot Damn Tamales

Online mail order Tex-Mex Tamales

Beef, Beer & Jalepeno Tamales

Online mail order Tex-Mex seafood tamale

Shrimp Tamales from Hot Damn Tamales

If you’re from Texas or New Mexico and have been out of either of those states for any time, admit it, you are craving a tamale. Hot Damn Tamales is way ahead of you and is on standby to quash that craving. They have 15 freshly made gourmet flavors at the ready like Cheese, Cowboy BBQ Brisket, Beef Beer and Jalapeno, Ancho Pork Tamales and some dessert flavors too. Texas Monthly and Martha Stewart-approved, order up a few dozen, invite in some friends and enjoy the taste of home. Vegan, vegetarian and gluten-free options are available.

Let’s Go Shopping!

Pricing: Average price of $14 per half a dozen.

Shipping: Flat rate shipping of $9.95 for 10 nearby states, this is a bargain. But if you are out of 1 day UPS Ground shipping range, shipping prices get steep. But hey, a craving is a craving.

Location: Fort Worth, Texas

Take me there!:


Povitica, Croatian Dessert Bread

Povitica, a traditional Croation, walnut-filled bread

Povitica (po-vuh-teet-sa) also known as Potica (po-teet-sa) is a traditional Croatian dessert bread, rolled into layers (think of a Babka–only richer) and traditionally filled with a paste of walnuts and honey–though there are many other fillings used as well.

If you already know that, chances are it’s because you are lucky enough to have a Povitica baker in the family, and if so, you are highly opinionated as to what it should look and taste like. Our family has been blessed with two excellent Povitica bakers who can be cajoled into making at least one at Christmas. But if a Povitica craving hits between major holidays, you can order from one of the following bakeries. It won’t be like what your grandmother or mom makes (nothing ever is!), but it’ll come near to hitting the spot.

Update 2022: Since writing this post, there are even fewer places to buy a povitica online. We once listed four options, now there are only two that we are aware of. You can still depend on Strawberry Hill Bakery, and now the Vermont Country Store sells povitica too.